PupLife Healthy Dog Supplies Home | My Account | Order Status | Help
Cart Shopping Cart: 0 items $0.00
Dog Care Tips | Dog Names | Dog Tags | Blog
Browse
Dog Apparel
Dog Beds
Dog Books & DVDs
Dog Bowls
Dog Cards
Dog Carriers
Dog Clean Up
Dog Collars
Dog Crates & Pens
Dog Food
Dog Gates
Dog Grooming Supplies
Dog Harnesses
Dog Health & Safety
Dog Houses
Dog ID Tags
Dog Leashes
Dog Strollers
Dog Toys
Dog Training Supplies
Dog Travel Supplies
Dog Treats
For The Home
Furniture
Holidays
Pet Gifts
Puppy Products
Sale Items

Styles
Classic Cool
Earth Friendly
Modern Chic
Rock Star

Holidays
Birthday
Christmas
Easter
Fourth Of July
Halloween
St. Patricks Day
Thanksgiving
Valentines Day
Weddings

Questions?
Shipping
Returns
Help Center
About Us
Contact Us
Site Map
Privacy

Fun Stuff
Dog Blog
Dog Names
Dog Care Tips
Gifts By Breed
Free Newsletter
Sites We Like
Link To Us
  Ask A Trainer with Judit Arroyo
Crate Training & Housebreaking: Not Two Sides of the Same Coin

Dog Crate
Home Series Collapsible Dog Crate
The Home Series dog crate sports a contemporary look and super strong construction. A solid choice for anyone who wants a portable dog crate that can also work in the house.

Power of Positive Dog Training

The Power of Positive Dog Training Book
Walk away from punishment-based training methods and learn how you can reward your dog to obtain and reinforce the behaviors you could only dream about achieving.

Biodegradable Puppy Pads

Simple Solution Natural Biodegradable Puppy Pads 46 Pk
Perfect for housebreaking your puppy. Good for your pet and the planet!


Question: We have a seven month old, spayed Rottweiler-Retriever mix. Unfortunately we did not start crate training her from the start but have now. She likes her crate, and goes to sleep at night after a few minutes of scratching and whining. She sleeps for about 4 hours and then wakes up. We stop water at 6pm, and take her out every hour from 6pm until "bed time". When she wakes up she needs to go outside and pee. Do you have any suggestions on how to get her to sleep through the night? - Judy, via email

Answer: There are two separate issues that need to be addressed: crate training and housebreaking. They should both be worked separately but congruently. The fact that your dog was not crate trained until later in her life shouldn't have an affect on her ability to "hold it" at night, unless she is able to "hold it" when out of her crate (at night). Therefore, let's address one issue at a time starting with crate training and followed by some housebreaking pointers.

While many people look at the crate as a negative tool or a place for punishment it should actually be your dog's safe place and second home. To accomplish this, you must create a positive association between your dog and her crate, using positive reinforcement dog training techniques. First, start feeding your dog in the crate so that she associates good things with it. You can also give her additional dog treats and goodies (like bones, treat toys, etc...) in her crate.

Another way to build a positive association is to train your dog within the context of the crate. Teach your dog to stay in the crate until you release her. Your goal is to have her want to stay in her crate even if you release her; this means that you will have succeeded in making the crate self-rewarding. Start by having her in the crate with the door closed. Approach the crate, open the door and immediately reinforce her (by placing a treat at the back of the crate) for being in the crate. This is counter-conditioning - your dog's first impulse will most likely be to jolt out the door when you first open it. After several repetitions, you'll notice that your dog will wait in the crate for you to place a treat at the back, and she'll voluntarily begin to wait for reinforcement. Now you can teach her that an open crate door doesn't necessary mean "come out". Continue to train your dog in the crate, and work on reinforcing your dog being calm and quite in the crate. To do this, approach the crate door place, your hand on the door handle and wait until your dog sits. The moment she sits open the crate and reinforce her. If your dog breaks her sit immediately close the door and step away. Your dog is not allowed to cross the threshold until she is released by you (whether or not the crate door is open). When you're able to open the door all the way without your dog breaking her sit release her from the crate. Once she's out of the crate stop all forms of reinforcement and ignore her. She will come to understand that it is in her best interest to stay in her crate because good things happen when she is inside. For more step-by-step guidance on crate training checkout Pat Miller's book, The Power of Positive Dog Training.

Now to address your second problem: there are many reasons why your dog might not be able to "hold it" throughout the night. Normally, when my clients come in with a specific problem we go through an extensive in-take consultation to collect even the most minute details of an individual's day-to-day life with their dog. In order for any trainer to develop an effective strategy, one has to be able to get to the root the problem. Some of the questions that come to my mind are:

- Is there a physical problem causing the unwanted behavior?
- How many times a day do you walk your dog?
- When exactly is "bed time", and is it consistent?
- How many times does your dog wake you up at night?

Before beginning any behavior modification program, be sure to address the physical question with your vet and rule out any medical problems such as a bladder infection or other internal issue that might be affecting your dog's ability to "hold it". After any physical ailments are ruled out, I would proceed with more training. It is important that you look at the bigger picture, and not just the "night" context. If you are walking your dog every hour you are putting her on a fixed schedule so that her inner clock might be set to go potty frequently during the day and continue throughout the night. Gradually extend the time between her potty breaks to build her muscle control and her ability to hold her bladder.

Next, think back to the first time you noticed this behavior. Did your dog initially wake up whining and crying? If so, what was your response? Did you ignore her or did you assume she was crying because she needed to go potty? If you took her out to potty each time she whined or cried your dog may have "trained" you to let her out of the crate on her schedule. Think about it, does she potty and then sleep through the night or does she continue to whine when you put her back in her crate? If the latter is the case, and she only whines because she wants to come out, working the crate games suggested above will help mitigate the problem by creating a positive association and breaking the cycle.

Additionally, you'll need to address your dog's exercise needs. As we trainers say, "a good dog is a tired dog!" A seven-month old pup needs lots of exercise and activity to stimulate her mind and body and hence, induce a good night's sleep. Make sure that your dog has plenty of high quality puppy supplies, including dog toys, puppy pads and interactive elements. Instead of walking your dog every hour give her appropriately spaced potty breaks throughout the day and then provide an extended exercise period (45 minutes to 1 hour) prior to "bed time" either by taking her to the dog park, playing fetch and tug games or even light jogging. As I mentioned previously, be sure to address your dog's physical abilities with your vet beforehand.

As a dog owner, it's important to be able to understand the reasons behind your dog's behaviors. You'll need to examine every detail and look for the cause of an unwanted behavior to effectively address it. Underlying causes might not always be clear and obvious, but we must always be aware that our dogs are learning from us all the time. Therefore, in addition to examining your dog's behavior, examine yours as well. How do you react to your dog and what are you consequently teaching her? Remember, problem solving involves both ends of the leash!

Judit Arroyo works in the day training program at Call of the Wild School for Dogs, Chicago’s premier dog training facility. She began her training career at age 17 and has developed a specialized interest in working with defensive dogs. Judit is active in competitive obedience and agility sports as well as Therapy Dogs International certification. Additionally, she is an AKC Canine Good Citizen evaluator.

Ms. Arroyo has a BA from DePaul University and is active in community outreach programs including Chicago Canine Rescue (CCR), New Leash on Life (NLOL) and has led fundraising efforts for Cook County Animal Care & Control. Judit serves as a Program Leader for Sit Stay Read! and is currently developing their dog training program.


Have a question for PupLife.com's Ask A Trainer series? Contact Us!

 Copyright 2003-2008 PupLife Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.  
 PupLife.com, Pup Life and the PupLife.com logo are all trademarks of PupLife Inc.